Finding Waldo: Why Making Chinese Friends is Difficult

Finding Waldo: Why Making Chinese Friends is Difficult
Jul 30, 2012 By Elaine Pang , eChinacities.com

Conveniences afforded by rapid modernization have made it possible for the average foreigner to get by (barely) in China without speaking a word of Mandarin. Translation software and supermarkets make survival without Chinese friends possible. Cloistered in work situations unconducive toward interacting with locals, it is possible to live in China without having a single Chinese friend. Some are perfectly happy to spend all their leisure time with fellow expats. A large proportion of foreigners, however, come to China to gain cultural experience and this cannot be attained in a friend-less vacuum.

Having a hard time making Chinese friends? Here are some possible reasons why, along with suggestions on how to bump up your chances at friendship in China.

Friendship defined, Chinese-style…

Before writing all locals off as insincere opportunists, try seeing friendship from their eyes. Chinese tend to use the word "friend" rather loosely – for everything from colleagues to casual acquaintances. In a name-dropping, guanxi-based society, contact details are usually requested within minutes of making an acquaintance. Following months of silence, a local acquaintance is capable of striking up a conversation like an old friend. Although, to be fair, networking is a perfectly legitimate pursuit back home.  Soulmate-type friends do exist in China – you just have to look harder for them. Having defined "friend", let’s move on to the causes of friendlessness.

Reasons why making Chinese friends can be difficult

1) Effect of nationality on "friend-ability"
Growing affluence in China means a growing appetite for the exotic and the imported, friends included. A foreign passport can work like a friend-magnet, at least until the novelty has worn off. It can also work the other way, with the recent rash of incidents involving foreigners behaving badly in China causing a significant amount of backlash and anti-foreigner sentiment. Not to mention that most Chinese already possess insecurities toward how foreigners view them. Lastly, not all foreigners are created equal. People from Western countries usually enjoy the warmest welcomes (sincere or interested), while foreigners from developing countries could find themselves looked down upon by locals. Relationships between countries are ever fluid and unpredictable, hence the effect a foreigner’s nationality may have on locals is something that is beyond one’s control. But having knowledge of how locals view people from different countries is useful in getting to know how they think.

2)  Cultural differences
Chances are, China differs from your home culture on at least four out of five of Hofstede’s Cultural Dimensions. Cultural differences are employed by both Chinese and foreigners to explain everything from differing service standards to political systems. Specifically, Chinese concepts of guanxi (connections) and mianzi (face) are often bewildering to those from meritocratic societies. Neglecting to build networks and failure to give face (adequate respect) are potential friendship landmines.

Those taking a long view of their stay in China would find going a step back and understanding Chinese history a worthwhile investment. Chinese are understandably proud of their "5,000 year-long history", which significantly and indelibly shapes current thinking and behaviour. In ancient China, guanxi did not have its current negative connotation as people worked hard at maintaining relationships. Recent history has eroded traditional relationships among Chinese as they continually seek immediate connections – a.k.a. the we’ve-met-once-therefore-we-are-friends phenomenon. A Chinese "friend" who seemed so warm and effusive in the first few meetings suddenly disappears after finding out his or her target’s financial or social position.

3) Language barriers
Adding to the seeminly insurmountable cultural barriers are language barriers which serve to widen the chasm between foreigners and locals. Especially considering that Mandarin Chinese is not an easy language to master for those learning it as an adult. Even fluent Mandarin-speakers meet accent discrimination in parts of China less accepting toward differently-accented Putonghua. Chinese looking to make foreign friends that can be used as language partners are not hard to find, but not every foreigner relishes being a free language-practice target. In rare cases where true friendship subsequently develops, the road is more often than not fraught with lost in translation potholes.

4) Not doing as the Chinese do
On a more mundane level, culture affects day-to-day activities like eating habits to leisure pursuits. Being in China but unable to do as the Chinese do could jeopardize chances at friendship in regions where locals are less tolerant of "Western" preferences. In places where cuisine options are more extreme, like hot and spicy Sichuan, not every foreigner is willing and able to join in their newfound friends’ weekly hotpot sessions. Ditto with mahjong and karaoke sessions. Being perceived as "different" could mean "not friendship material", especially in inland parts of China less exposed to foreigners.

5) Being technologically hip in China
Policies in China have also affected communication methods. Young working adults favor QQ and Weibo over Skype and Twitter; Tudou and Youku over YouTube. Sure, many scale the Great Firewall, but such expeditions are usually confined to satiating curiosity on YouTube, news sites and the odd Skype session with foreign friends. Suggesting that a local friend sends you an email will not go down as well as leaving a message on QQ.

6) Sometimes, the answer lies within
So far, the discussion had been confined to environmental factors, but to a large extent, friendship also depends on the individual. The workplace is a good place to develop friendships due to the hours spent there but some workplaces, like universities, may deliberately separate local and expatriate staff. Choice of leisure activities is also another factor. For example, friendships forged in pursuit of common interests are typically deeper than those made under the strobe-lights of the disco. Lastly, the clichéd adage, "if you want a friend, be a friend" applies. Being more outgoing helps in drawing out locals who tend to be more self-conscious and introverted, as effusive ones often turn out to be shameless opportunists.

To increase chances at friendship in China

  1. Get on a local social-networking or microblog site like QQ or Sina Weibo – especially helpful to build networks with young working adults.
  2. Remember, when using humor, that Lost in Translation is not just a movie – at best, efforts at lightening the atmosphere could fall flat; at worst, they could prove offensive.
  3. Try not to decline an invitation without very good reason for doing so.
  4. Pursue a hobby that locals would engage in, such as Chinese painting or joining a gym. Joining an English corner or attending a local religious group are other possibilities.
  5. Avoid "sensitive" or controversial topics on the first few meetings, especially politics or news that cast China in an unfavourable light. Being critical of China is something of an art form in and of itself!

 

Related links
Making (and Keeping) Chinese Friends
Learning From Your Chinese Friends (Without Subjecting Them to an Interrogation)
Be Warned! Top 10 Chinese-Westerner Misunderstandings (According to Chinese)

Warning:The use of any news and articles published on eChinacities.com without written permission from eChinacities.com constitutes copyright infringement, and legal action can be taken.

Keywords: friendships in China Chinese friends cross-cultural relationships China how to meet Chinese people culture gap in China

8 Comments

All comments are subject to moderation by eChinacities.com staff. Because we wish to encourage healthy and productive dialogue we ask that all comments remain polite, free of profanity or name calling, and relevant to the original post and subsequent discussion. Comments will not be deleted because of the viewpoints they express, only if the mode of expression itself is inappropriate.

904754559

Hello, nice to meet you. I can help you contact Chinese friends. My email is 904754559@qq.com

Mar 11, 2022 09:35 Report Abuse

flip

I wish there were any iota of truth in what u are saying.........have u never been asked how much u earn even at a first meeting with some Chinese? to the contrary most have the notion that all "laowais" are affluent!!!! please ask any of your Chinese friendS if they have ever been to Beijing and many will quickly respond ' i DONT HAVE MONEY" though thats way off the answer.
Friendship is just mutual, both must give and receive....be it ...........date, food, whatever. I never accept a second treat from any of my chinese friends and they love me for that. and u know why? i want them,,,,,,,,,,and just assures them that their company is enough.

Aug 07, 2012 18:57 Report Abuse

Mateusz

Would you rather have the term "foreigner" used? At least "westerner' is a step up in the right direction. It at least acknowledges us as something beyond "one of those" in the eyes of Han Chinese.

Aug 02, 2013 07:28 Report Abuse

flip

I would rather say learn how to speak chinese and u wouldn't have to worry about being caucasian...........we were and are all born this way and no one has control over nature. nothing can change that yet we can learn as many languages as we can. nature is kind enough not to handicap humanity but bestows upon us a tremendous capacity.

Aug 08, 2012 17:30 Report Abuse

Guest434920

If by that you mean don't be Caucasian, then you're right. If you want real friendship, beyond being that "foreigner" who can possibly provide some benefit, so better to be kept around, then be Han Chinese.

Aug 02, 2013 07:26 Report Abuse

mike

What a stupid and lazy piece of work. I really hope no one gets paid for this. Really? cultural differences and language barriers?? how enlightening.

Jul 30, 2012 16:52 Report Abuse

Chaching

Recluse,
That's the hard truth. It took me a little bit longer to accept the fact that most of the time I was being used. Becoming a hermit is easy in China. After purging my social network of the "freeloaders," I too found myself with very few actual friends after all these years. Finding true Chinese friends has proven quite difficult. My wife is Chinese, but she is kind of on the quiet side herself. A lot of our Chinese friends are usually much older than the two of us.

I will say that in a society where "guanxi" reigns with an iron fist, being anti-social will definitely hurt your abilities to move forward. I just hate playing the game sometimes. I am looking for "friends," not necessarily "assets." You know what I mean?

Aug 01, 2012 06:48 Report Abuse