All comments are subject to moderation by eChinacities.com staff. Because we wish to encourage healthy and productive dialogue we ask that all comments remain polite, free of profanity or name calling, and relevant to the original post and subsequent discussion. Comments will not be deleted because of the viewpoints they express, only if the mode of expression itself is inappropriate.

1

sm90
comment|51927|299894

The article is linked in underneath... it's not hard to find

Oct 22, 2014 08:43 Report Abuse

2

27pence
comment|51904|306901

I looked at his webpage at Nottingham. He has lived in the UK since 1985.

Oct 21, 2014 17:41 Report Abuse

3

andyinshenyang
comment|51908|83100

Unfortunately I don't think he's been out much since 1985 as his description of early closing shops, punks and football hooligans in the UK may have been right in the 80's but it's a very different place now. That or Nottingham has really changed since I was there ten years ago!

Oct 21, 2014 18:16 Report Abuse

4

dongbeiren
comment|51896|303147

This article is truly pathetic. China is a beacon of cleanliness unlike the cesspools of New York and Paris. And people from western countries are flocking here for the great health care. Let's not forget the enlightened justice system in China where all are treated equally under the law unlike in America where money rules. When you pay people 50 cents to churn out propaganda you end up with garbage like this. Dear CCP, I want to apply for a job as a wumao but I demand wu kuai for each post because they will be more than ten times as convincing as this crap. So everybody wins.

Oct 21, 2014 15:37 Report Abuse

5

Kaiwen
comment|51894|91738

"Foreigners who are able to experience the high-speed rail in China are very lucky. The trains run directly from one station to another, it is a very efficient way to travel". I particularly like this one. Before I came to China, I couldn't imagine trains that go directly from one station to another. I have gotten used to the ones where the driver does a detour between stations so that he can have tea with his auntie. Thanks the Chinese for thinking about us passengers and and going directly from one station to another!

Oct 21, 2014 14:45 Report Abuse

6

macjp
comment|52023|287163

Yes great trains. However, Chinese railway stations and the travelling on Chinese trains has got to be the closest thing to purgatory or hell I've witnessed....the hassle of buying the ticket,stampedes to the gates, souless platforms, people p@ssing from the corridors of the aisle into the bowl, warm beer, rubbish everywhere.......don't start me on the sleeper train!!

Oct 25, 2014 10:03 Report Abuse

7

Samsara
comment|51893|239770

If an article includes the words "This is a true fact!", I don't think you need to mention that the author is Chinese. On a side note, I continue to be astonished by what constitutes "professor" status in China.

Oct 21, 2014 14:29 Report Abuse

8

ilcornalito
comment|51890|293558

I have lived in 6 countries for more than 3 years in each. All of them are the "best" and have the "best" of something and "that is why so many foreigners go work and live there". I learned we are all the best and we all suck.

Oct 21, 2014 13:38 Report Abuse

9

Stiggs
comment|51888|276259

I wonder what the Chinese netizens thought of this article.

Oct 21, 2014 13:20 Report Abuse

10

royceH
comment|51916|27883

They are all chubbied up. Not very big chubbys though.

Oct 21, 2014 22:29 Report Abuse

11

tbh66
comment|51882|84606

Why would echinacities even considering publishing this piece of crap on its site. shame on you echinacites!

Oct 21, 2014 11:42 Report Abuse

12

admincomments
comment|51885|305340

Hi tbh66, The point of the China Media section is to translate Chinese articles that are trending in the Chinese media, to give an insight into the media of the country we are all residing in. eChinacities did not write this list, nor do we agree with the views presented. We hope that with this insight you will be able to understand why we have posted this. Kind Regards, Admin

Oct 21, 2014 11:58 Report Abuse

13

tbh66
comment|51933|84606

nevertheless, the article published on home page (opinion or not), is crap. As is evident by the majority of postings here.

Oct 22, 2014 09:43 Report Abuse

14

sm90
comment|51938|299894

Dude, I think that's the point!

Oct 22, 2014 11:00 Report Abuse

15

Samsara
comment|51876|239770

So… A Chinese male’s desperate fantasies about what he WISHES Western people would say. Some of these examples are hilarious. Others are just mind-boggling in their degree of stupidity, denial, and detachment from reality. --- “Law and order.” OK, so last week a forced demolition crew (group of hired criminals who brutalise villagers and demolish their homes while the local government and police are paid off to turn a blind eye, all of which signifies LAW AND ORDER) in Yunnan got attacked by the locals whose houses they were destroying. The crew killed two villagers. Then they got surrounded, tied up, and set on fire. Four died of burning. And that’s not to mention the ear cutting, finger snipping, penis biting, baby flushing, forced abortions, student rape, doctor stabbing, and numerous other commonplace occurrences in Chinese “society”, to which the police say “there is no evidence that anything happened”. You’re a shining example of law and order to us all, China. --- “The War on Drugs”. America’s “War on Drugs” isn’t working, because draconian punishment doesn’t deter drug use. It CAUSES drug use. And according to this article an American (allegedly) congratulated a Chinese person because of China’s equally retarded stance on drugs. We’re all so envious, China. We envy China’s brutal punishments and rapidly escalating drug problem. Wait… what? I’m lost. --- “If you have been on the dirty subways of New York City or the trash-filled alleys of Paris, you will be able to appreciate the serenity and peacefulness of China and Chinese cities.” And then he woke up. And realised he wasn’t in the Tang dynasty, and that China is composed entirely of dirty, trash-filled alleys, whereas Paris isn’t. I guess if you ignored the construction sites, mountains of rubble, garbage everywhere, polluted water, dilapidated buildings, uncivilised people, phlegm and fecal matter, omnipresence of cancer-causing grey dust, and lack of trees, China would be a normal country. But still not really worth boasting about. --- My personal favourite: “The Japanese often admire how much land China has” HAHAHA! Telling fanciful stories about people admiring your size highlights a particular inadequacy. “Oh… China… You’re so BIG!” Chinese people write the most amazing self-parodies (if only they knew what they were writing). --- To summarise this article: The writer has spent years desperately fishing for compliments about his country (as Chinese people are apt to do). Occasionally a foreigner will give in to the constant prompting and say something they don’t mean to make him shut up, and he will treasure their words like jewels for the rest of his life. And write articles about it.

Oct 21, 2014 11:04 Report Abuse

16

yongge
comment|51889|304546

Once you have lived in a place with no law and order or respect for human life, you will realise how safe China really is. I have visited 29 countries, most of them more than once or twice, and have lived for long periods of time in a few of them, and can honestly say that I felt safer in China than in most of them.

Oct 21, 2014 13:25 Report Abuse

17

Samsara
comment|51892|239770

There's your problem right there. You have to compare China to a third-world country to make a positive comparison. Unfortunately though, the article begins by citing ENGLAND and GERMANY. The rest of its claims and comparisons are utterly farcical.

Oct 21, 2014 14:07 Report Abuse

18

yongge
comment|51899|304546

China is essentially a third world country, so fair to compare with others, in which case it far surpasses them. I have been to both England and Germany, I do not consider them particularly safe.

Oct 21, 2014 16:31 Report Abuse

19

Samsara
comment|51902|239770

So... Your argument is that China is better than other third-world countries. Congratulations - It is. Meanwhile, the rest of us are discussing the article above, which is comparing China to first-world countries, and quoting completely fictitious "foreign" points of view, like "We envy China's law and order" (spoken by no foreigner, ever).

Oct 21, 2014 17:39 Report Abuse

20

sm90
comment|51976|299894

Have you ever considered the fact that your bike was stolen in China but not in Japan/Korea was maybe because of poverty and desperation rather than malicious intent or whatever you seem to insinuate that it represents? Can't compare the two nations based on bike stealing.

Oct 23, 2014 15:59 Report Abuse

21

humbug
comment|51977|286395

@eorthisio- are you insinuating that sexual harassment and sexual assault of women aren't a problem in Japan or Korea? really?

Oct 23, 2014 16:06 Report Abuse

22

ilcornalito
comment|52007|293558

When somebody asks me the classical "Do you like China?" I always reply "It's the best country in the world" and just look at their cheeks turning red of pride. It also saves time and they don't ask anything else.

Oct 24, 2014 12:42 Report Abuse

23

petecowell
comment|51875|52501

I doubt seriously that the original article was written by Professor Yao. A quick scan of his UoN personal page reveals that he's lived in the UK since the 80s, and his serious published work tends to be a bit more in depth and academically focused than the content of this piece. It doesn't seem like the sort of thing he would write, although I could be wrong. http://www.nottingham.ac.uk/chinese/people/shujie.yao

Oct 21, 2014 10:53 Report Abuse

24

hunana
comment|51879|283840

Do you think ifeng put his name on a piece that he didn't write?

Oct 21, 2014 11:23 Report Abuse

25

RiriRiri
comment|51880|281533

It is very well known that no foreigner can understand such deeply complex language as Chinese. Therefore, Chinese can post all the shit they fancy under the radar, as long it's in Chinese. Seriously, they do that all the time. Why do you think most propaganda posters are never translated? There's so much fun in them though.

Oct 21, 2014 11:35 Report Abuse