Man-Made Suffering: The Status of Animal Rights in China

Man-Made Suffering: The Status of Animal Rights in China
Nov 15, 2011 By Kyle Mullin , eChinacities.com

Mongrels. Mutts. Tramps.

There’s no shortage of vile slang for strays in the English language. Vagrant dogs are shooed away like pests in all corners of the world, as we squirm at the thought of the tics and worms that might be thriving under their matted fur.

Yet Westerners show an extra special disdain for the way dogs are treated in Asia. Our superiority complex has pushed us in the past to even slander the whole region with snide dog eating jokes. Animal rights groups like The World Wildlife Foundation (WWF) and The World Society for the Protection of Animals (WSPA) have helped raise the standards for most four legged creatures in the developed world, leaving it just as easy for us now to sneer down our snouts at the track records of less developed nations. So much so that it’s easy for us to miss the slowly grumbling animal protection movement in China.
Of course it’s true that China has been guilty of animal rights abominations. Dozens of articles – from both eastern and western news sources – detail those atrocities. The standard theme is the consumption of dog and cat, an apparently savoury sweet meat laced with nutrients that keep the eater warm in winter. But there’s no shortage of animal rights atrocities in any link of the Chinese food chain – from hormone addled chickens to circus bears being forced through flaming hoops. If enough visitors gather at the tiger pits in Harbin, curators will drop live cows inside the fences to fend for themselves for the sake of spectacle.    

A growing social conscience…

But the judgmental streak of Westerners like myself might not be justified. Not now, because animal rights are growing in China. This past April, an intensely aggressive battalion of activists spontaneously came to the rescue of a truck brimming with stray pooches after rallying together on Chinese social media websites. The dogs were bound for pots in China’s northern regions.

The socially conscious mob wasn’t only looking to rescue the pups—they were pushing a whole new Chinese canine paradigm. Because the middle class is growing, so too is the common man’s love of man’s best friends. In other words dogs, felines and an assortment of other cute creatures are fairing better simply because more Chinese citizens can afford to care for them.

If a Good Samaritan driver is willing to spontaneously force such a carnivorous caravan off the road, if a group of compassionate locals are eager to band together so quickly for such a cause, and if millions of followers light up their computer monitors with the story and punch in their support under the ‘Comments’ section, then surely China’s animal rights standards are bound to change.

But if that animal rights herd has indeed gathered in China, it has yet to stampede. Chinese legislator. Zhou Ping was quoted in The Economist a few years ago, after attempting to pass China’s first national animal-welfare law. Zhou said she was pushing for a ban on the selling or devouring of dog and cat meat. The penalty would be a 5000 RMB ($730 U.S.) fine or a 15 day jail sentence. But although Zhou’s congressional cohorts publicly agreed that animal protection measures were necessary, no specific action was taken.

In late June the Asia for Animals Conference 2011 was held in the south-western city of Chengdu. During the summit some of the nation’s leading animal advocates pushed for “the timely passage of China's first comprehensive animal welfare law - the China Animal Protection Law,” which had been shelved at the national legislature since the release of its draft in September 2009.

…Looking for a voice and people’s help

Zhou is far from the only Chinese animal rights champion. There’s the Chinese Animal Protection Network (http://capn-online.info/en.php), The Asian Animal Protection Network (http://www.aapn.org/links.html), along with international groups like WSPA (which has information on how you can get involved at http://www.wspa-international.org/helping/Default.aspx). More grassroots animal rights collectives working in China include the Animals Asia Foundation (which can be contacted for further information here http://www.animalsasia.org/index.php?UID=P709D24JPR00) and the China Small Animal Protection Association (which takes donations from this page http://www.csapa.org/english/Donation.htm).

Judging by the current state of their work, such organisations are in dire need of that kind of funding and outreach. Last spring’s canine highway rescue was nobly lopsided. The activists succeeded in stopping the truck and seizing the captive dogs, but what plan did they have to house and care for these animals afterward? Like a dog chasing its tail, the activists had no idea what to do once they caught it – they made no effort to arrange for homes or shelters for the pooches, much less veterinary services to tend to any of the injured animals. Why rescue someone now that you might leave at risk later? Negligence is hardly noble.

Their quick, social-network-fuelled scheme to stop the truck was very impressive. Now China’s animal rights activists need to follow through with that laudable ambition – to provide health and housing to the creatures they adore, all the way to the higher courtrooms and lobby groups that can shelter them once and for all.
 

Related links
Should Expats Being Their Pets to China?
How Would You Kill These Dogs? China Vs. The West
The Five Essential Stages to Buying a New Puppy in China

Warning:The use of any news and articles published on eChinacities.com without written permission from eChinacities.com constitutes copyright infringement, and legal action can be taken.

Keywords: animal rights in China Chinese animal rights organizations protecting animals in China changing values towards animals in China

5 Comments

All comments are subject to moderation by eChinacities.com staff. Because we wish to encourage healthy and productive dialogue we ask that all comments remain polite, free of profanity or name calling, and relevant to the original post and subsequent discussion. Comments will not be deleted because of the viewpoints they express, only if the mode of expression itself is inappropriate.

Steve

The problem is not many animals in China are killed humanely. Especially dogs and cats, which is why there is a bad reputation. "Production animals" like pigs, sheep, cows, chickens, etc are killed pretty quickly simply because it's more cost effective.

It's the attitude of "beating the crap out of the puppy or kitten to make it taste better" is where the problem stems from.

Dogs and cats have been domesticated by human beings to be companion animals for longer than the history of China, while livestock has been bred for centuries to be big dumb meat factories. Pigs can be clever, but basically as long as they have available food, they could care less. Seriously. Even if it's a pet.

That's my main issue with dog and cat eating. 10,000 years ago people discovered some animals were useful for certain things and then as a species we've bred them for those purposes. Livestock for meat, dogs for companionship, hunting, etc. Over that time traits vanish and others appear. Dogs were bred to bond with humans, cows to make more meat, be docile, and stupid. Where are all the wild cows? Put a common cow out on the plains of Africa and see how long it survives.

This to me is the difference.

Asia has always been a weird place for dealing with animals mostly because of a much higher superiority complex than the "western" one mentioned in this article. Look up "pig toilets".

Nov 15, 2011 20:39 Report Abuse

jixiang

What's wrong with eating dogs in principle? If you can eat a pig or a cow (which are just as intelligent), then why not a dog? As long as it's killed humanely.

Nov 15, 2011 18:00 Report Abuse

TRUE

it is the whole baby seal thing, killing them is bad because they are cute with big puppy dog eyes, while dogs actually have big puppy dog eyes.

Nov 15, 2011 18:35 Report Abuse

jixiang

oh yes people in Christian countries all unconditionally love everyone, don't they? Please.

Nov 15, 2011 18:02 Report Abuse

so true

sad but true. i believe human rights were completely destroyed in.... oh about 1989. crushed even.
It is safer to just not think about a silly thing like human rights, so instead animal rights is the way to go.

Nov 15, 2011 18:39 Report Abuse