Foreign Wealth Disparity in China: Income, Perception & Cost of Living

Foreign Wealth Disparity in China: Income, Perception & Cost of Living
Nov 16, 2012 By eChinacities.com

Judging by the plethora of different reasons for foreigners coming to live in China, for defined or undefined periods of times, the very wide array of economic and career backgrounds they hail from comes as little surprise. While there are an increasing number of foreigners here out of dire economic circumstances, many chose China rather than China choosing them. Some come for an attractive salary package, others for a lifestyle switch. They are here out of free will, or because it is the smart thing to do, given China’s ever-solidifying position as a pillar of the future global economy.

Income disparity among expats in China
Excluding Hong Kong, Macau and Taiwan, China’s 2010 population census reports that there are 600,000 foreigners living in China, less than half of whom have work permits. As the Chinese economy keeps growing, so will the number of expats. Yet the income they are bringing in varies wildly depending on a number of factors.

The education sector, where many expats make a living, is an area with particular disparity. While some unfortunate teachers find themselves scraping by at 4,000 RMB per month or less (even Peace Corps volunteers make almost half of that as teachers), mega-qualified teachers with doctorates and the right position can earn up to 30,000 RMB every month. Many teachers fall into the 5,000-15,000 RMB range, mostly dictated by location and experience as much as credentials. Although there is significant room to bargain and make a lot for overtime hours, many teachers are not making as much as those expats working for multinational companies in other industries.

Meanwhile, there are plenty of expats that rake in a killing. Full-time employees in other industries, including auto, hi-tech, chemical, engineering, pharma and consumer goods make 13,000 – 53,000 RMB per month on average. Not to mention attractive benefit packages that include between 10,000 – 50,000 RMB housing allowance per month and up to 12,000 RMB each month for educating a child, according to AON Hewitt’s 2010 Expatriate, Returnee and China Hired Foreigner, Compensation and Benefits Survey. In these other industries foreign consultants earn at least 10,000 RMB per month. Aside from the human resources department, foreigners hired in their home country and assigned to a position in China typically make more than if they were hired directly in China. These assignees, at least those outside of the education industry, are typically the highest earners among Chinese expats.

Perceived wealth disparity among expats

While not all foreigners’ earnings are equal, most are making between 10-300 times as much as their Chinese counterparts and spending a tenth to a third of what it costs to live in the developed world. This creates an ideal situation for expats making loads or only a little.

Like many expats all across the world, many don’t leave their homeland just for the paycheck. That means at a private English school I’ve seen a retired (and economically comfortable) American heartland rancher working alongside an Aussie twenty-something who chose China for the amount of his paycheck he can stash away to make a down payment on property at home — and just about everything in between. In the internet industry, I’ve known a Chinese-culture obsessed search engine optimizer who worked as little as necessary to spend more time enjoying his days with his new bride. I met an online advertising manager who’d been headhunted in the U.S. and who bolted eagerly back home after only six months in Shanghai.

There is no foolproof method for determining a Westerner’s position on the economic ladder. For example, from a glance, it is much easier to figure out which rung a Chinese person has achieved than their Western counterparts. Quite simply, the Chinese usually buy what they can afford, whereas the credit-driven consumer class of the West (particularly the U.S.) has allowed the “fake it till you make it” crowd to not only exist but to become damn near normal.

What’s more is that most Western’s don’t have to lift a finger to prove they are wealthy, it’s assumed by locals. For the time being that is an accurate assumption. In tier 1 cities, like Beijing and Shanghai, the sheer number of foreigners and history of the foreign population means there is more competition among foreigners and a larger scale on who has what and exactly how much effort is needed to solidify a desired status level. In tier 2 and 3 cities, the requirements to prove your status are lower, evidenced by the wow-a-foreigner-factor that persists in these cities. Indeed, you are wealthy until proven otherwise.

Cost of living in China

Everyone likes a bargain. The wealth disparity among foreigners in China is a good reminder of that. Despite the escalating costs of living, in comparison to most Western cities in the same category (i.e. Boston to Beijing, Chicago to Chongqing, Houston to Wuhan, Shanghai to San Francisco), China is still a steal, even if expats who have been here for a while harp otherwise.

Living in China is a bargain. Everyone wants to spend less when possible, no matter where they sit on the wealth or income spectrum. Relativity aside, the have-nots, the have-somes, and the have-lots are all better off economically living in places that cost less than what they are accustomed to. Not worrying about price is a load off the mind.

Sure this can change over time. Maybe you didn’t initially consider a weekly foot massage or bottle service at a club as a part of your routine; nevertheless, these perks have monetarily become irrelevant in the grander bank account scheme of things. It’s easy to be less conscious of how much you’re spending when things cost so little comparatively. Even with increasing costs, many Western foreigners reap these economic advantages in a variety of ways in their day-to-day lives in China. Such living conditions are attractive to everyone on the wealth scale — no matter how much they are bringing in every month from their Chinese day job.
 

Related links
The Chinese Teacher’s Paycheck
The Beginning of the End for Lavish Expat Lifestyles
Are Foreigners in China Overpaid?

Warning:The use of any news and articles published on eChinacities.com without written permission from eChinacities.com constitutes copyright infringement, and legal action can be taken.

Keywords: wealth disparity in China wealth gap between foreigners in China lifestyles and wages of foreigners in China Expat salaries in China

8 Comments

All comments are subject to moderation by eChinacities.com staff. Because we wish to encourage healthy and productive dialogue we ask that all comments remain polite, free of profanity or name calling, and relevant to the original post and subsequent discussion. Comments will not be deleted because of the viewpoints they express, only if the mode of expression itself is inappropriate.

Clarice


You guys said, "Impress"??? That's the word....Ha,ha,ha,ha,ha....
So, any better reason out there to prove this word meaning???
Here the are: COMPLEX OF INFERIORITY .
Guys, be always confident is what matter, and than forget the "face"!!!

Nov 17, 2012 08:35 Report Abuse

Johnny

Excellent post ambivalentmace. Couldn't agree more. While I can afford buying new top mobile, I still well use my 4 years old samsung, it serves me as good as the first day I bought (second hand). For me, it is way more important that I can go to any restaurant and don't have to look at prices, but can freely choose what I want to eat, instead of having new toy, filled with all kind of crap, you don't need. As I have some local friends in more than decent jobs, they always look at my phone and then at me. While they don't say anything, I can read from their eyes, they think why is it, that I don't have new phone. I will buy new one now, but only because I want to use chinese characters in phone, which current doesn't have.

Also prefer to buy things with cash, however card can be convenient for major purchases.

Back to phones again, what I really don't understand is when you go to some shops, subway sandwich restaurants or similar places, where clerks and waitresses have 2-3k salary (if at all) and see them with new iphones. Some of them even waiting long lines to buy it the very next day, when it comes out. It just amazes me each time. It is like you are slave to consumption. Do these people feel better just because they get a new toy?, How about doing some real work and try to switch career to feel better about yourself. Buying new toy, which you can't afford in first place doesn't do anything good for you, but make you feel better for a day. On 2nd day you are back at the beginning, or worse, as you spent money with which you could do something useful instead.

New toy in the pocket, but empty refrigerator at home and empty wallet in other pocket. Go figure. Of course, there are people like that all around the world.

Nov 16, 2012 20:15 Report Abuse

chris

for sure life here is cheaper, if you live the chinese life style.
my employees get 3000 rmb a months here in the countryside of shanghai, and they also can survive! To be honest i can live easly with 500-700 rmb weekly here.....
just a matter of lifestyle....

Nov 16, 2012 17:04 Report Abuse

SunZu

Factor in the following to Costs of living and goods.

1. Chinese like to over pay, especially for luxury goods. It helps them gain face.

2. INFLATION- thats why beer is now $9.

Result: When central banks increase the money supply so aggressively to keep their currency low, more money is in the system, more people have paper money and if they are willing to spend much more than normal supply and demand would allow, then the result is modern China.

I would argue against the author however and say under a non manipulated economy, your cost of living should be more, because what you desire has to be imported, creating inefficiencies. Sure you can get what you want here, but it is not the same quality and it cost the same or more.

Regardless, interesting article.

Nov 17, 2011 17:52 Report Abuse

SunZu

Someone (author) has a hard on for China...

Nov 17, 2011 17:43 Report Abuse

Samuel Burgess

A great explanation.

I have to explain things to people back home in their countries that China is not at all cheap when top Western brands are concerned.

Nov 18, 2012 01:32 Report Abuse

SunZu

I agree with you. I think the author is out of touch with the realities here. These days Chinese are not "buying what they can afford." They are trying to keep up with the Zhang's.

If you lived in a country where everyone around you is getting rich, you would start trying to at least show you are making progress to buy saving up half a year's pay for an iPhone.

Nov 17, 2011 17:55 Report Abuse

carlstar

you must have no confidence in your skill as a teacher to stick with the same place for crappy pay.

Nov 16, 2012 22:56 Report Abuse