Guangdong Man Caught with Prostitute Successfully Sues Police for Sending him to Labor Camp

Guangdong Man Caught with Prostitute Successfully Sues Police for Sending him to Labor Camp
Sep 06, 2013 By

A Guangdong man who was caught red-handed with a prostitute and who was sentenced to six months of re-education through labor after 15 days in detention, sued police authorities for subjecting him to an overly heavy sentence. Remarkably, the man won his appeal after his second attempt at suing the public security bureau.

On December 10, 2011 at around 1:30, 23-year old Pan Liang was caught by police leaving a motel after paying a woman 50 RMB for sexual services. Yuexiu District police immediately took him away and detained him for 15 days. After the 15 days, he was sent to a labor camp for six months.

Pan Liang thought that his punishment was too severe and brought the public security organ to court, arguing that his combined detention and re-education through labor sentence was a violation of the Administrative Punishment Law of China. However the court believed that re-education is a compulsory measure and ruled in favor of the public security bureau.

As a result, Pan Liang took his case to the Guangzhou Intermediate People's Court arguing that he had only committed a “vice” once. This time the court took his side, stating that there was an insufficient basis to send him to re-education camp. The court also ruled that the Public Security Bureau pay him 22,000 RMB in compensation.


Warning:The use of any news and articles published on without written permission from constitutes copyright infringement, and legal action can be taken.

Keywords: Guangdong man sues public security bureau


All comments are subject to moderation by staff. Because we wish to encourage healthy and productive dialogue we ask that all comments remain polite, free of profanity or name calling, and relevant to the original post and subsequent discussion. Comments will not be deleted because of the viewpoints they express, only if the mode of expression itself is inappropriate.



How did they KNOW she was a prostitute. How did they KNOW what he had paid her? How did they KNOW he had had sex? A prostitute is a person like anyone else. what if the man was her boyfriend? Is she the ONLY prostitute in town? Is HE the ONLY customer?

Sep 12, 2013 18:30 Report Abuse



30 million more men than women, need I say more?

Sep 09, 2013 13:44 Report Abuse



This may be a bit of naivety on my part, but since my first time in China, I have never seen a Chinese police officer with a gun. When I visited Beijing I did and once in Shanghai airport when they were bringing money in from an armored car, but I never saw local police officers carry them.

Sep 06, 2013 14:29 Report Abuse



This was a raid on a brothel, they probably were armed in case any gangster-types were inside.

Sep 06, 2013 23:56 Report Abuse



The picture is not necessarily of the crime mentioned in the article. eChinacities (and many other sites) will many times just use some appropriate looking stock photo from the internet.

Sep 07, 2013 08:25 Report Abuse