17 Ways to Learn Like the Chinese

17 Ways to Learn Like the Chinese
Oct 01, 2012 By eChinacities.com

Twenty-third in science. Thirty-first in math. As the grand old USA lags further behind the rest of the world in education, the temptation to model ourselves after countries that continuously churn out strong students grows. And when it comes to education, we could do far worse than to look at China and do likewise. While there was no national ranking for China, a recent global assessment placed Shanghai at the top of all three categories it tested: math, science, and reading. Hong Kong came in second, third, and fourth in those categories. For better or worse, here are 18 ways Americans can begin to learn like the Chinese.

1) Hire a tutor
To truly experience learning like the Chinese, you'll need a tutor at your side. An estimated 80% of Chinese parents engage tutors for their children, either on a regular basis or before big exams like the infamous gaokao.

2) Head to "cram school"
While much tutoring in China is done one-on-one, so-called "cram schools" are also quite popular; so popular, in fact, the Ministry of Education had to pass a law barring the schools from serving children under age 6. The after-school education programs are comparable to American SAT prep classes and can cost thousands of dollars a year.

3) Train teachers weekly
Even the schools most interested in keeping teachers well-trained don't require it weekly. In China, students have the benefit of learning under teachers who dedicate a half-day each week to being trained by a "master teacher." Unlike in the U.S., this additional training is not for any extra credit, money, or certification; it is simply part of the job.

4) Do more homework
The typical American student is obsessed with minimizing homework time, but in China not only do some students spend four hours on homework every night of the week, some even assign themselves extra homework. Of course, all this homework comes with a price: it's students' No. 1 source of their lack of sleep.

5) Abandon intellectual curiosity
Students and their parents who have experienced both countries' education systems are often shocked at the contrast between the levels of freedom students have in their learning. China is laser focused on standardized testing, despite fears that such focus is stifling innovation. If you really want to learn like the Chinese—which clearly is an excellent means of learning math and science—be prepared to see creativity fall by the wayside.

6) Put in more hours
One of the most visible differences between Chinese and American education is the length of time students put in studying. The Chinese are regularly cited as studying for 12 hours a day, either at school or at home. When the children are home, half of them are not allowed to play outside as it takes away from study time, according to their parents.

7) Improve teachers' pedagogical knowledge
Studies have shown American students are at a disadvantage in their learning because their teachers trail their Chinese counterparts in their knowledge of teaching. (In one study, less than 5% of American teachers could create an accurate word problem for a math question, compared to 40% of Chinese ninth-graders.) To learn like the Chinese requires teachers who can engage students with relatable illustrations of the subject matter they are trying to teach.

8) Cut out recess
One of the cornerstones of American learning has been the idea that long periods of instruction should be broken up by a chance for kids to exercise in the fresh air. However, recess is not a part of the school day in China. And despite its proven benefits to kids, many American schools have already begun to do away with it.

9) Learn in Chinese
Granted, this is outside the realm of possibility for most Americans. But one intriguing explanation for Chinese students' superiority in math is that English is too illogical and hinders math learning. For example, what we would read as "two-thirds" literally means, in Mandarin, "out of three parts, take two." It's a subtle difference but it illustrates the fact that the Chinese have the benefit of learning with a more logical language.

10) Memorize, memorize, memorize
China's educational background is centuries of memorizing the writings of Confucius. As mentioned, Chinese education today focuses on standardized testing. The result is a culture dependent on rote memorization, which, again, can produce world-beating scores in math and science.

11) Don't ask questions
Because they are so concerned with the concept of "face," students do not ask teachers questions and vice versa because it would imply one or the other was not smart enough to either teach or understand the material. Students who need help wait until after class to approach the teacher. The obvious benefit for the class is the lesson is never interrupted by questions, although this could also be a negative as multiple students may also require further explanation.

12) Turn on the pressure
American students may feel stressed in high school around time for the SAT, and some parents may push their kids to excel in academics from an early age. But nowhere else in the world are children required to learn under such immense pressure as China. Polls have shown a majority of primary school children worrying "a lot" about exams. The competition for spots in the top universities in enormous, with the praise or shame of family and society hanging in the balance.

13) Respect the teacher
"Student stabs teacher" brings up way too many Google hits with American settings. They may be quiet, but Chinese students learn in an environment of mutual respect between themselves and the teacher. Hand-in-hand with that respect goes the ancient idea of following the teachings imparted from the teacher. In the past, these teachings were philosophical writings; today they're math equations.

14) Do your exercises
While the unstructured fun of recess may be out, that doesn't mean the Chinese neglect physical exercise in their learning regimen. By government mandate, at assigned times all students rub their eyes, both under ad over, to stay healthy. In the afternoon there are stretches in the aisles. These exercises will be part of students' lives for no less than 12 years.

15) Break out the IV
Remember the pressure we said Chinese students are under? How else to explain a roomful of high school students hooked up to IVs pumping amino acids into their bodies to keep them studying longer for the dreaded gaokao university entrance exam. Now, come one American juniors studying for the SAT: let's see those IVs!

16) Don't separate kids by learning ability
In years past and continuing today, it has not been Chinese practice to separate gifted students from the rest of their peers. Instead, students are grouped at random early on and this grouping will remain practically unchanged throughout their school years, with stronger students serving as informal tutors for their struggling classmates.

17) Require a foreign language early on
Imagine if American students were so preoccupied with learning Spanish, some officials began to worry about their English skills. This is exactly what education is like in China, only their preoccupation is with learning English. The majority of students will spend 10 years or more learning the foreign language. If you want to learn like they do, pick up a beginner's guide to Mandarin and study for a good decade or so.

Source: onlinecolleges.net          
 

Related links
Sex Education in China – In the Dark or With the Lights on?
A Crash Course on the Chinese Education System
An Education: How China's System Differs from the West's

Warning:The use of any news and articles published on eChinacities.com without written permission from eChinacities.com constitutes copyright infringement, and legal action can be taken.

Keywords: United States and Chinese education comparison advantages of Chinese learning

6 Comments

All comments are subject to moderation by eChinacities.com staff. Because we wish to encourage healthy and productive dialogue we ask that all comments remain polite, free of profanity or name calling, and relevant to the original post and subsequent discussion. Comments will not be deleted because of the viewpoints they express, only if the mode of expression itself is inappropriate.

sinobear

Not one to pick apart a post step-by-step, but I couldn’t help myself with this one:
1) Hire a tutor
Get a teacher to babysit your kid. Chinese kids who are failing are routinely subject to paying their teachers more money for “remedial lessons” that never take place (although their marks go up magically).
2) Head to "cram school"
Get someone else to babysit your kid. All “cram schools” promise big and deliver nothing. But hey, it gets your kid out of the house for hours more per day.
3) Train teachers weekly
Get the intern away from the office and QQ so you can get more sleep. I’ve never seen, nor heard, of Chinese teachers being trained by “master teachers”, although I’ve seen a lot of meetings discussing the possibility of training teachers at some later date (if it doesn’t cost any money and if the senior teachers do not have to interrupt their nap-times doing so).
4) Do more homework
My students have lots of homework and lots of homework time. They do little with what they have. They spend far more time trying to cheat, copy and avoid homework than they actually commit to the task. Most of their homework consists of “make-busy” work that results in a big red check-mark on their page, devoid of constructive criticism, regardless of how much or how little the students produce.
5) Abandon intellectual curiosity
Become a mindless automaton. You will achieve high scores in math and science, but will be unable to get a career in any field requiring these skills because you cannot “think outside of the box.” Companies today want to hire potential managers, not burger-flippers.
6) Put in more hours
One of the most visible lies presented in this article. I’ve heard so much about the hours put in by Chinese students and I’ve yet to actually see this in practice. My students have a longer school day in total hours in school…but taking into account all their breaks and the mandatory nap time, they probably spend just as many hours in class and studying as their American peers.
7) Improve teachers' pedagogical knowledge
“Facts” are a little wrong here…studies have shown Chinese students are at a disadvantage in their learning because their teachers trail their world counterparts in their knowledge of teaching. (In one study, less than 5% of Chinese teachers could solve an English word problem for a math question, compared to 40% of American second-graders.) As English is the lingua-franca of math, science, computer science, medicine, etc, Chinese teachers are at a disadvantage as they cannot, and usually could care less, to keep themselves abreast of the latest in advances in the aforementioned areas.
8) Cut out recess
Cut out time for social interaction. Reinforce the idea that children are to be mindless automatons. Put the final nail in the coffin for creativity and self-expression.
9) Learn in Chinese
Granted, this is outside the realm of possibility for most Americans. But one intriguing explanation for Chinese students' superiority in math is that English is too illogical and hinders math learning. For example, what we would read as "two-thirds" literally means, in Mandarin, "out of three parts, take two." It's a subtle difference but it illustrates the fact that the Chinese have the benefit of learning with a more logical language. Which works so well that a 25% discount is understood by the Chinese to mean ? off the price.
10) Memorize, memorize, memorize
China's educational background is centuries of memorizing the writings of Confucius. As mentioned, Chinese education today focuses on standardized testing. The result is a culture dependent on rote memorization, which, again, can produce world-beating scores in math and science…even though those very same students cannot reproduce the same results a year later.
11) Don't ask questions
Because they are so concerned with the concept of "face," students do not ask teachers questions and vice versa because it would imply one or the other was not smart enough to either teach or understand the material (which is entirely true). Students who need help wait until after class to approach the teacher. The obvious benefit for the class is the lesson is never interrupted by questions, although this could also be a negative as multiple students may also require further explanation.
12) Turn on the pressure
Crank up the suicide rates, and those for physical and mental illnesses.
13) Respect the teacher unless that teacher is a foreigner.
"Student stabs teacher" brings up way too many Google hits with American settings. They may be quiet, but Chinese students learn in an environment of mutual respect between themselves and the teacher. Hand-in-hand with that respect goes the ancient idea of following the teachings imparted from the teacher. In the past, these teachings were philosophical writings; today they're math equations.
14) Do your exercises
Rub your eyes..no better way to insure getting a cold. Damage your optic nerves. Go back to straining your eyes from the back of a classroom with a chalkboard 150 meters away.
15) Break out the IV
Saline and sugar at 30 RMB a bag. This practice would make the Victorians proud.
16) Don't separate kids by learning ability
because it won’t matter in the end. Poor performing students will pay for “remedial lessons” from the “teacher” and receive the same grades as the students who excel (and those students also learn an important lesson…it doesn’t matter how hard you try, money wins in the end).
17) Require a foreign language early on
Imagine if American students were so preoccupied with learning Spanish, some officials began to worry about their English skills. This is exactly what education is like in China, only their preoccupation is with learning English. The majority of students will spend 10 years or more learning the foreign language. If you want to learn like they do, pick up a beginner's guide to Mandarin and study for a good decade or so. You’ll be fluent in two years…the Chinese will never be fluent in English because they prefer to translate rather than learn.

Oct 03, 2012 02:00 Report Abuse

Alex

How true, it shows how stupid the US is, the western countries who took up their stupid education model and are now paying for it with illiterate and bigoted young people who think they know everything.
Yes you say, they can think, but, can they listen not likely, respect that is just a complete joke!! Come on you sepos and demean me for what's it worth!!

Oct 02, 2012 01:21 Report Abuse

Alex

Thankyou for your stupid red thumbs, you can't educate Americans because they are always right!! Yeah sure!

Oct 02, 2012 02:14 Report Abuse

Alex

Well if you read what I wrote, I was only refering to the article which is about education...but Rain has to put words into my mouth and crap into everyones ears. Just typical of you young american guys, yes you will rule the world...in your dreams

Oct 02, 2012 03:32 Report Abuse

Alex

I am not generalising about americans, just talking about the way everything in america is controlled by money. You guys probably don't understand, american politics and idology and how it is controlled by the almighty dollar. I can't quite understand why I have a selective memory or why my honesty is questioned...I suppose this is because american youths can think for themselves and belittle others whilst doing it!! Smoke it man!!

Oct 02, 2012 04:36 Report Abuse

Alex

Tim can you point out my mistakes? maybe my spelling and grammar is from a different era or a country other than yours. I didn't think I offered answers, just my opinion, I really try to keep up with change, am I suppose to write academically?...which would be pointless with this forum anyway
P.S sorry about any mistakes

Oct 03, 2012 01:28 Report Abuse